Hathras: SC calls it horrible, UP says step in to cease narratives

Written by Ananthakrishnan G
| New Delhi |

Updated: October 7, 2020 3:11:55 am

Hathras: SC calls it horrible, UP says step in to stop narrativesSecurity on the village of Hathras sufferer Tuesday. (Express photograph by Abhinav Saha)

Calling the Hathras incident “horrible… extraordinary and stunning”, the Supreme Court Tuesday requested the Uttar Pradesh authorities if witnesses within the case of the alleged rape and homicide of a 19-year-old had been offered safety and if the household of the sufferer had a lawyer.

The state authorities, on its half, urged the Supreme Court to oversee the probe into the incident.

The bench of Chief Justice of India S A Bobde and Justices A S Bopanna and V Ramasubramanian, listening to a writ petition searching for a probe by the CBI or a court-appointed Special Investigation Team, mentioned it needed to listen to from the events on the scope of the proceedings within the matter already earlier than the Allahabad High Court and “how we will make them extra related”.

On October 1, the Allahabad High Court, taking suo motu cognizance of the case and the hurried cremation of the sufferer’s physique, ordered senior officers of the state authorities and police to be current on the subsequent listening to on October 12.

The High Court bench of Justices Rajan Roy and Jaspreet Singh mentioned the officers should temporary it on the standing of the investigation within the case and clarify the sequence of occasions that led to the cremation and the household’s criticism in regards to the method by which it was carried out.

The petition within the Supreme Court was filed by activist Satyama Dubey and advocates Vishal Thakre and Rudra Pratap Yadav.

“There is little question that that is stunning,” the CJI remarked when Dubey’s lawyer referred to the incident and mentioned it had shocked the petitioner.

Senior advocate Indira Jaising, showing for legal professionals who had expressed concern over the incident, mentioned the matter needs to be transferred to Delhi and the household granted witness safety.

Intervening, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, showing for UP, mentioned the witnesses had been already beneath police safety. Asked by the CJI to position this on report, Mehta mentioned he would file an affidavit by Thursday.

The CJI mentioned “the incident is extraordinary and stunning”. He mentioned this was why the bench was listening to the intervenors although it was unsure if that they had any locus on this prison case.

Mehta informed the bench that the state was not opposing the petition. “We usually are not opposing this”, he mentioned, including “there are narratives and narratives, however the unhappy fact is {that a} younger woman has misplaced her life… allow us to not sensationalise”.

Mehta mentioned individuals and political events had been offering their very own narratives and urged the courtroom to watch the probe.

He mentioned “supervision of this Court is necessary for ruling out” the totally different narratives.

To again his argument, Mehta mentioned a voice clip appeared to counsel {that a} reporter was instigating the household of the sufferer to place forth a selected account.

The bench took exception to a number of functions being filed in the identical matter and mentioned, “please perceive that there isn’t any have to duplicate considerations within the courtroom of legislation”.

The CJI mentioned “please perceive that we’re under no circumstances condoning the incident. It is a horrible incident however the query is what number of comparable arguments ought to we hear? … Court needn’t hear the identical argument by totally different events”. He clarified that “this isn’t a touch upon the incident”.

The Allahabad High Court, the CJI mentioned, is a Constitutional courtroom already seized of the matter. He mentioned the Supreme Court “will make sure the investigation half is clean”.

📣 The Indian Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel (@indianexpress) and keep up to date with the most recent headlines

For all the most recent India News, obtain Indian Express App.

© The Indian Express (P) Ltd

Source link


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here